Delo Welding and Industrial Supply Corporation


Case Study in Holecutting: Large filter system fabricators require easy to use portable drills and fast holemaking tools... this New York manufacturer finds 40 to 60% time-saving solutions
Concerns for the environment, health issues, and cost economies are spiraling demand for filters and filter systems -- for both consumers products and industrial applications -- upward. For companies like Filtertech, Inc. of Manlius, NY, that's the good news. The bad news is that this same global market expansion has put additional pressure on their production capacity, creating challenges for faster processing to meet deliveries while at the same time requiring product quality be continuously improved. At Filtertech with assistance from DELO Welding & Industrial Supply and Sales Bill Foley, however, they've found two solutions that have helped with both time savings and quality enhancement. Both answers were provided by Hougen Manufacturing (Flint, MI), producers of Rotabroach® Portable Magnetic Drills and Rotabroach® Annular Cutters for holemaking.

Started in 1969, Filtertech custom designs and fabricates liquid filtration systems for coolants and lubricant used in a variety of industrial settings, most notable among these are manufacturers who draw copper and aluminum wire products, along with systems for steel mills and automotive component processing. And, as indicative of the industries served, the firm's filtration systems are large. According to Plant Foreman, John Brown-Paul, Filtertech produces systems which may be equipped with cylindrical tanks, or in many cases what is referred to as "flat bed" units. The flat bed systems typically fall within a range of 8 to 70 feet long and are complete with pumping mechanisms, filtration media (usually a paper-type filter, automatically indexed to present clean surfaces), and conveyor for transport of sludge and contaminate particles to collection containers.

With respect to the fabrication of the flat bed filtration systems, Mr. Brown-Paul says is what prompted the company to seek a more efficient holemaking technology. The conveyor of a flat bed unit is mounted to the filter housing using a series of bolts placed every 5" for strength and stability on both sides of the conveyor throughout its length. For the longer systems, this could mean well over 300 holes have to be drilled. The size of the fabrication components such as the mounting rails are too large and awkward which precluded taking them to stationary machine tools. The holes, ranging from 5/8" to 13/16" diameter drilled through I-beams and channel materials up to 3/4" thick, depending upon the system design, had to be drilled using hand held electric drills and twist drill bits.

Mr. Brown-Paul reports that the most effective way to drill the holes in the past was to use three steps -- a pilot hole, an intermediate size drill, then the finish size tool. Add to this a secondary operation to remove the jagged burr and each hole could easily take 10 to 15 minutes for completion. He also mentions that operator fatigue created by holding and pushing the hand held drill played a role in slowing down production as well as greater care being required trying to maintain the roundness and alignment of the holes.

With the increase in orders and production times running long, Mr. Brown-Paul decided to try the Rotabroach Model 10904 magnetic drill and annular cutters from Hougen. Within drilling just a few holes with the magnetic drill and cutters, it was apparent to Mr. Brown-Paul that he had found the right solution. "Overall, we're probably saving 40 to 60% of the time we used to spend drilling the holes," he says. "There's little fatigue factor now, the holes are round and always in the right alignment with no drill wander as twist drills are prone to do. And, for most applications, we no longer have to deburr the holes because of the cutters' smooth cutting action."

These results experienced by Filtertech are attributable to the magnetic drill and cutter combination. First, the Model 10904 magnetic drill is light and compact, weighing just 28 pounds and measuring 16-7/16" x 7-3/16" x 8-1/4". Its drilling capacity is 1-3/8" hole diameter through materials up to 2" thick. A powerful electromagnetic base provides a dead lift hold strength of over 1700 pounds on average while rear mounted, accessible controls and a side-to-side reversible feed handle configuration enhance the unit's ergonomics.

The Model 10904 also incorporates Hougen's exclusive safety features to insure a safe work environment. These include a motion sensor which shuts down the drill motor if shift or lift of the magnetic base is detected. A two stage power on switch prevents the drill rotation unless the magnet has first been engaged, and, in the case of a power interruption, safety circuitry will keep the drill motor off after power is restored until the start button is manually depressed.

The Rotabroach "12,000-Series" Annular Cutters and their alternative cutting design were the other contributor to the improved drilling times. One of the reasons twist drills present drilling problems is that the tools have a center point. It is this point on the drill that is often referred to as the "dead zone" because very little if any cutting action takes place. The reason? As the diameter of the drill approaches zero at the center point, the surface cutting speed, being the product of spindle revolutions x diameter, also drops off to near zero. The dramatic drop in SFM correlates into additional thrust being required, a leading cause of tired arms, hands and general fatigue.

Annular cutters, on the other hand, offer an important design difference from the traditional twist drill bit. Annular (meaning shaped like a ring) cutters like the "12,000-Series" Rotabroach cutters are hollow so there is no center point or "dead zone" to contend with. All of the cutting edges are at the periphery of the tool, thus SFM is virtually constant -- there is no pushing or thrusting of a non-cutting point through the material.

Because the annular cutters are hollow, this also means that less of the stock is being converted into chips. As the Rotabroach Cutter cuts around the hole, the center portion remains a solid core, and once the cut is complete, is ejected from the tool as a slug of material.

Another important difference between a Rotabroach Annular Cutter and a twist drill is the number of cutting edges. Typical twist drills have two flutes which tend to form the long string chips. The annular cutters, however, can have up to 12 cutting edges to more evenly distribute cutting forces for longer tool life and better surface finishes within the hole. What's more, the patented Hougen-Edge tooth geometry incorporated into the Rotabroach design has been field proven to provide a rounder hole than can be achieved with twist drills and produces virtually no burr on the breakthrough side of the stock, so secondary deburring and chamfering operations can be eliminated.

To Filtertech and Mr. Brown-Paul, the combined improvements in drill operation and cutter performance have made the difference to the company's productivity and quality -- and they're now using the Rotabroach Magnetic Drill and cutters throughout their operations, continually finding new applications and faster drilling times.

 
Serving Central New York Since 1939